Abstract

Surgical education relies heavily on textbooks, yet operating room realities reveal critical gaps in practical application, decision-making, and medico-legal compliance under India’s new criminal laws (BNS, BNSS, BSA 2023). This interview-based review captures reflections from an experienced surgeon on common procedures appendectomy, cholecystectomy, hernia repair, and trauma laparotomy highlighting experiential lessons in tNumber handling, complications, and clinical bedside documentation. Emphasis falls on BNSS §183 (mandatory videography) and §176A (viscera protocols), transforming surgeons into evidentiary stewards. Comparative tables juxtapose textbook ideals against practice realities, advocating simulationintegrated curricula to minimize litigation risks and enhance outcomes. These insights equip trainees for the art-science-humanity triad of surgery. Medical education provides a strong scientific and clinical foundation; however, the realities of medical practice often reveal important gaps between what is taught during undergraduate and postgraduate training and what is required for effective, compassionate patient care in practice. Drawing on reflections from a lifetime of surgical practice in India, this article examines two broad domains of learning: aspects of medical training that later prove inadequate or incomplete, and the essential professional competencies that are rarely taught but gradually acquired through experience. These include managing atypical clinical presentations, decision-making under uncertainty, caring for patients with multiple comorbidities, effective ommunication, expectation management, documentation, ethical dilemmas, grievance redressal, teamwork, and emotional resilience. Through illustrative clinical anecdotes, the interview dialogue highlights the “unwritten curriculum” of medicine that shapes doctors long after formal education ends. Recognising and integrating these lessons into medical training may help prepare future generations of Indian doctors to be not only clinically competent but also ethically grounded, communicatively skilled, and better equipped to navigate the complexities of contemporary medical practice.

• 1.   Slotnick HB; How Doctors Learn: Education and Learning across the
• 2.   Medical-school-to-practice Trajectory; Acad. Med. 2001;76:1013–1026.
• 3.   Ignite Clinical Institute; From Perfect Diagrams to Real Patients: Why Textbook Knowledge Falls Short; Blog: https://www. igniteclinicalinstitute.com/blog/from-perfectdiagrams-to-real-patients-why-textbookknowledge-falls-short
• 4.   Agusti A. The disease model: implications for clinical practice. Eur Respir J 2018; 51:1800188 [https://doi.org/10.1183/13993003.00188- 2018].
• 5.   Open Horizons; God in the Operating Room. Process Theology and Surgery; Blog: https://www.openhorizons.org/god-inthe-operating-room-process-theology-andsurgery.html
• 6.   Guardian Church Goods; In the Operating Room: Prayer While in Surgery; Blog: h t t p s : / / w w w . g u a r d i a n c h u r c h g o o d s . com/2025/10/08/in-the-operating-roomprayer-while-in-surgery

Data Sharing Statement

Funding