Advertisement!
Author Information Pack
Editorial Board
Submit article
Special Issue
Editor's selection process
Join as Reviewer/Editor
List of Reviewer
Indexing Information
Most popular articles
Purchase Single Articles
Archive
Free Online Access
Current Issue
Recommend this journal to your library
Advertiser
Accepted Articles
Search Articles
Email Alerts
FAQ
Contact Us
Pediatrics Education and Research

Volume  6, Issue 2, May - August 2018, Pages 53-60
 

Original Article

A Comparative Study Based Grading of Malnutrition by WHO Z Score and IAP Classification

Sanjeev Suman1, Sonal Vyas2, Swati Raipurkar3

1Senior Resident, Department of Pediatrics, K.D. Medical College, Hospital & Research Center, Mathura, Uttar Pradesh 281406, India. 3Professor and Head, Department of Pediatrics 2MD, Department of Pathology, Index Medical College, Hospital & Research Centre, Indore, Madhya Pradesh 452001, India.

Choose an option to locate / access this Article:
90 days Access
Check if you have access through your login credentials.        PDF      |
|

Open Access: View PDF

DOI: DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.21088/per.2321.1644.6218.2

Abstract

Serious malnutrition is all around us and yet it is not obvious, for it exhibits the Iceberg phenomenon”. By Anthropometric assessment one can detect the sub-clinical malnutrition very easily. Anthropometric measurements obtained in children are usually compared with that of a “reference standard”. In developing countries anthropometry despite its inherent limitations still remains the most practical tool for assessing the nutritional status of the children. Biological, epidemiological and statistical evidence suggests that wasting and stunting represent different processes of malnutrition. Low height-for-age (stunting) is a principal indicator of long term growth impairment caused by malnutrition in the past. The present study aims at comparing the prevalence of malnutrition in WHO Z Score classification and IAP classification. 

Method: About 400 children in the age group of 1-5 years were studied for their Anthropometric indices. The anthropometric measurements were performed using the standard WHO anthropometric measuring tools. Standardized methods were used in all measurements and were compared with standard HARVARD classification of IAP and WHO Z Score classification.

Result: Overall prevalence of malnutrition was found to be 67.5% according to IAP. Among 67.5% malnourished children the prevalence of underweight was more in girls (51.8%) than boys (48.1%). According to WHO classification prevalence of malnutrition was 68.7% of which 27.5% had severe malnutrition. Among 68.7% of underweight children about 25.7% were found to be below -3SD. Among 59.2% of stunted children about 26.5% below -3SD were observed. Among 13.5% of wasted children about 2.6% below -3SD were observed. According to IAP criteria among underweight (67.5%), preschool children, Grade I were 55.9%, Grade II 23.7%, Grade III- 16.2% and Grade IV were 4.07%.

Conclusion: In the current study it was observed that the Z Score system obtained the result with 1.2% precision as compared to that of IAP classification. Thus it can be concluded that Z Score system is more accurate in early diagnosis of malnutrition. 

Keywords: Malnutrition; IAP; Anthropometric; Anemia.


Corresponding Author : Sonal Vyas, MD, Department of Pathology, Index Medical College, Hospital & Research Centre, Indore, Madhya Pradesh 452001, India.